THE WAR BETWEEN THE STATES (II)

The Death Toll      Almost as many soldiers died during the Civil War as in all other American wars combined.  Union combat deaths totaled 111,904; another 197,388 died of disease, 30,192 in prison, and 24,881 as a result of accidents. Another 277,401 Union solders were wounded.  Confederate casualties were nearly as high, with approximately 94,000 combat deaths, 140,000 deaths by disease; and 195,000 men wounded.

     Over half of all deaths were caused by disease.  As a result of poor sanitation, primitive medical practices, and contaminated water supplies, the average regiment lost half its fighting strength from disease during the first year.

The Second American Revolution

     During the war, the Republican-controlled Congress enacted a series of measures that carried long-term consequences for the future.  The Homestead Act of 1862 provided public land free to pioneers who agreed to farm the land for five years.  The Morrill Act of 1862 helped states establish agricultural and technical colleges. Congress also authorized construction of the nation's first transcontinental railroad.

     The Civil War also brought vast changes to the nation's financial system.  Before the Civil War, the federal government did not issue paper money.  Instead, paper notes were issued by more than 1,500 state banks in 1860, which issued more than 10,000 different kinds of currency.

     To end this chaotic system and to impose federal regulation on the financial system, Congress enacted two important pieces of legislation.  The Legal Tender Act of 1862 authorized the federal government to issue paper money.  Because these notes were printed on green paper, they became known as greenbacks.  The National Bank Act of 1863 created the nation's first truly national banking system.

      As finally adopted by Congress, the National Banking Act of 1863 chartered national banks which met certain requirements, made the notes of national banks legal tender for all public and private debts, and levied a tax of 2 percent on state bank notes, which gradually increased over time.  By imposing a tax on state bank notes, the federal government forced state banks to join the federal system.  By 1865, national banks had 83 percent of all bank assets in the United States.  After 1870, interestingly, state banks made a comeback; they avoided the tax on their bank notes by issuing checks.

The Confederacy Begins to Collapse      By early 1863, the Civil War had begun to cause severe hardship on the southern home front.  Not only was most of the fighting taking place in the South, but as the Union blockade grew more effective and the South's railroad system deteriorated, shortages grew increasingly common.  In Richmond, food riots erupted in April 1863.  A war department clerk wrote: "I have lost twenty pounds, and my wife and children are emaciated."

     The Confederacy also suffered rampant inflation.  Fearful of undermining support for the war effort, Confederate leaders refused to raise taxes to support the war.  Instead, the Confederacy raised funds by selling bonds and simply printing money without gold or silver to back it. The predictable result was skyrocketing prices.  In 1863, a pair of shoes cost $125 and a coat, $350. A chicken cost $15 and a barrel of flour $275.

     Defeatism and a loss of will began to spread across the Confederacy.  Military defeats suggested divine disfavor.  Hardships on the home front generated discontent within the ranks.

     In the South, the imposition of a military draft in April 1862 produced protests that this was "a rich man's war and a poor man's fight."  Although the law made all able-bodied men ages 18 through 35 liable for three years' service, the draft law allowed draftees to pay a substitute to serve for him (the North adopted a similar draft law in March 1863).  Further aggravating tension was enactment of the "Twenty Negro Law" in October 1862 which exempted one white man from the draft on every plantation with 20 or more slaves.

The New York City Draft Riots
new york city draft riots

     As the war dragged on, enthusiasm faded and class tensions flared. In the North, the worst mob violence in American history took place in New York City in July 1863, two weeks after the Battle of Gettysburg.  About 120 people were killed, mainly by police and soldiers.  Irish Catholic immigrants and their children had been egged on by Democratic leaders who told them that Republicans wanted to free the slaves in order bring them north to replace Irish workers.  During four days of rioting, mobs lynched at least a dozen African American men, destroyed draft offices, burned and looted black neighborhoods and the homes of leading Republicans and abolitionists.

Blacks in Blue

4th US Colored Artillery
The 4th US Colored Artillery

     By early 1863, voluntary enlistments in the Union army had fallen so sharply that the federal government instituted an unpopular military draft and decided to enroll black, as well as white, troops.  Indeed, it seems likely that it was the availability of large numbers of African American soldiers that allowed President Lincoln to resist demands for a negotiated peace that might have including the retention of slavery in the United States. Altogether, 186,000 black soldiers served in the Union Army and another 29,000 served in the Navy, accounting for nearly 10 percent of all Union forces and 68,178 of the Union dead or missing.  Twenty-four African Americans received the Congressional Medal of Honor for extraordinary bravery in battle.

     Three-fifths of all black troops were former slaves.  The active participation of black troops in the fighting made it far less likely that African Americans would remain in slavery after the Civil War.

     While some white officers, like Robert Gould Shaw (1837-1863), who commanded the 54th Massachusetts Regiment, were proud to lead black troops in battle, others exhibited a deep resistance.

Fort Wagner      Black soldiers participated in the war at great threat to their lives.  The Confederate government threatened to summarily execute or sell into slavery any captured black Union soldiers--and did sometimes carry out those threats.  Lincoln responded by threatening to retaliate against Confederate prisoners whenever black soldiers were killed or enslaved.

     In July 1863, the 54th Massachusetts Infantry, the first black regiment raised in the North, led an assault against Fort Wagner, which guarded Charleston, South Carolina's harbor.  Two of Frederick Douglass's sons were members of the regiment.  Over forty percent of the regiment's members were killed or wounded in the unsuccessful attack, including Colonel Robert Gould Shaw, a member of a prominent antislavery family, who was shot dead in the charge.

The Battle Against Discrimination      During the war, African American troops also faced a different kind of battle: a battle against discrimination in pay, promotions, and medical care.  Despite promises of equal treatment, blacks were relegated to separate regiments commanded by white officers.  Black soldiers received less pay than white soldiers, inferior benefits, and poorer food and equipment.  While a white private was paid $13 a month plus a $3.50 clothing allowance, blacks received just $10 a month, out of which $3 was deducted for clothing.  Furthermore, black soldiers were not provided with the enlistment bonuses commonly given to white soldiers, and, until the end of the war, the federal government refused to commission black officers.

     Within the ranks, black troops faced repeated humiliations; most were employed in menial assignments and kept in rear-echelon, fatigue jobs.  They were punished by whipping or by being tied by their thumbs; if captured by the Confederates, they faced execution.  But despite these trials, African American soldiers won their fight for equal pay (in 1864) and in 1865 they were allowed to serve as line officers.  Drawing upon the education and training they received in the military, many former troops became community leaders during Reconstruction.

     One Union captain explained the significance of black military participation on the attitudes of many white soldiers.  "A great many [white people]," he wrote, "have the idea that the entire Negro race are vastly their inferiors.  A few weeks of calm unprejudiced life here would disabuse them, I think.  I have a more elevated opinion of their abilities than I ever had before.  I know that many of them are vastly the superiors of those...who would condemn them to a life of brutal degradation."

Towards Gettysburg



lee and jackson
Lee and Jackson

     After the Battle of Antietam, Lee's forces retreated into Virginia's Shenandoah Valley with almost no interference.  Frustrated by McClellan's lack of aggressiveness, Lincoln replaced him with General Ambrose E. Burnside (1824-1881).  In December 1862, Burnside attacked 73,000 Confederate troops at Fredericksburg, Virginia.  Six times Burnside launched frontal assaults on Confederate positions.  The Union army suffered nearly 13,000 casualties, twice the number suffered by Lee's men, severely damaging northern morale.

     After the defeat at Fredericksburg, Lincoln removed Burnside and replaced him with General Joseph Hooker (1814-1879).  In May 1863, Hooker tried to attack Lee's forces from a side or flanking position.  In just ten minutes, Confederate forces routed the Union army at the Battle of Chancellorsville.  But the Confederate victory came at a high cost.  Lee's ablest lieutenant, Stonewall Jackson, was accidentally shot by a Confederate sentry and died of a blood clot.

     Despite Confederate victories at Fredericksburg and Chancellorsville, the Union showed no signs of giving up.  In a bid to shatter northern morale and win European recognition, Lee's army launched a daring invasion of Pennsylvania.

     When his forces drove northward into Pennsylvania, Lee assumed, mistakenly, that Union forces were still in Virginia.  When he suddenly realized that Union forces were in close pursuit, he ordered his forces, which were strung out from Maryland to Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, to converge at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, a central location where a number of roads met.  Lee, who did not want to risk a battle until he had gathered all his troops together, ordered his men not to engage the enemy.  But on July 1, 1863, a Confederate brigade ran into Union cavalry near Gettysburg and the largest battle ever fought in the West Hemisphere broke out before anyone realized what was happening.

The Battle of Gettysburg

gettysburg dead
Dead at Gettysburg
Click here for maps of Gettysburg
     On the evening of July 1, most of Lee's army of 75,000 reached Gettysburg.  Meanwhile, most of the 90,000-man Union army of General George Meade (1815-1872) arrived at Gettysburg that same evening.

     On July 2, Lee tried to attack Union positions from the left and right flanks, but northern troops repelled the attack.  The next day, the Union army, which expected Lee to attack again on the flanks, reinforced its flanks. But Lee launched a frontal attack on the center of the Union lines, which came as a shock and a surprise. However, a frontal assault against a well-fortified defensive position on a hill was very unlikely to succeed.  Some 15,000 Confederate troops, led by General George E. Pickett (1825-1875), marched three-quarters of a mile into withering Union rifle and artillery fire.  Although about a hundred Confederate soldiers succeeded in temporarily breaking through the Union defenses, the northern lines held firm.  When Lee finally ordered a retreat back into Virginia, it became clear that the Confederacy had suffered a disastrous defeat.

     Nearly 25,000 Confederate soldiers were killed, wounded, or missing in action at the Battle of Gettysburg. After Gettysburg, Lee was never able to mount another major offensive.

Vicksburg
vicksburg
Click on the image for a larger view

     The four days between July 1 and July 4, 1863 marked a major turning point of the Civil War.  Beginning in mid-May, Ulysses S. Grant's troops had begun a siege of Vicksburg, Mississippi. Located on a bluff overlooking the Mississippi, Vicksburg allowed the Confederacy to control river traffic between Memphis and New Orleans. The day after the defeat of Lee's army at Gettysburg, Vicksburg surrendered. Five days later, Union forces captured Port Hudson, Louisiana.  These victories gave the North complete control of the Mississippi River and isolated confederate territory west of the Mississippi from areas east of the river.

     After the defeats at Gettysburg and Vicksburg, southern morale began to sag.  Yet despite military defeats, inflation, shortages, desertions, the flight of thousands of slaves, and flagging resolve, the Confederacy continued to fight for another 22 months.

The Thirteenth Amendment      The Emancipation Proclamation freed only those slaves in states still at war.  As a wartime order, it could subsequently be reversed by presidential degree or congressional legislation.  The permanent emancipation of all slaves therefore required a constitutional amendment.

     In April 1864, the Senate passed the Thirteenth Amendment to abolish slavery in the United States. Opposition from Democratic Representatives prevented the amendment from receiving the required two-thirds majority.  If McClellan and the Democrats had won the election of 1864, as Lincoln and most Northerners expected in the summer, the amendment would almost certainly have been defeated and slave emancipation repudiated as a war aim.  Only after Lincoln was reelected did Congress approve the amendment.  Ratification by the states was completed in December 1865.

Total War
william tecumseh sherman
Gen. William Tecumseh Sherman

     Initially, Lincoln and his generals anticipated a conventional war in which Union soldiers would respect civilians' property.  Convinced that there was residual unionist support in the South, they expected to preserve the South's economic base, including its factories and rail lines.  But as the war dragged on, the Civil War became history's first total war, a war in which the Union sought the Confederacy's total defeat and unconditional surrender.  To achieve success, Union officers such as Ulysses S. Grant and William Tecumseh Sherman believed that it was necessary to break the South's will to fight.  Sherman summed up the idea of total war in blunt terms: "We are not only fighting hostile armies," he declared in 1864, "but a hostile people, and must make old and young, rich and poor, feel the hard hand of war."

     A year earlier, a general order was issued that declared that military necessity "allows of all destruction of property" and "appropriation of whatever an enemy's country affords necessary for the subsistence and safety of the Army."  This order allowed soldiers to destroy anything that might be of use to the Confederacy.

The 1864 Presidential Election





andrew johnson
Andrew Johnson
McClellan
George B. McClellan

     The 1864 presidential election was one of the most critical in American history.  At stake was whether the war would end in unconditional surrender or a negotiated settlement, which might result in the preservation of slavery as a legal institution.  Even though hundreds of thousands of slaves deserted to Union lines during the war, it is not at all inconceivable that slavery could have survived if the President had not been committed to emancipation.  During the American Revolution a third of Georgia's slaves had been freed by the British, and tens of thousands of Virginia's slaves had escaped bondage.  Nevertheless, slavery survived the revolutionary upheavals in the South, and soon began to flourish and expand.  Similarly, slavery was temporarily reinstituted by the French in St. Domingue and greatly expanded in Guadeloupe, Martinique and other colonies despite the Haitian Revolution and the French emancipation decree of 1794.

     In August 1864, Lincoln expressed his view in moving words.  Observing that over 130,000 blacks were fighting to preserve the Union, he said that they were motivated by the "strongest motive...the promise of freedom.  There have been men who proposed to me to return to slavery the black warriors.  I would be damned in time & in eternity for so doing.  The world shall know that I will keep my faith to friends and enemies, come what will."

     Deeply anxious about the election's outcome, Republicans and pro-war Democrats formed the National Union Party, which re-nominated Lincoln and selected Andrew Johnson (1808-1875), a former Democratic Senator from Tennessee, for Vice President. Johnson replaced Lincoln's first Vice President, Hannibal Hamlin (1809-1891), a former U.S. Senator from Maine.

     As their presidential nominee, the Democrats chose General George B. McClellan, who opposed the Emancipation Proclamation and who ran on a platform which condemned Lincoln for "four years of failure" and called for a negotiated end to the war.

     Some Radical Republicans also opposed Lincoln's reelection. Lincoln had asked Congress to seat representatives from three recently conquered Confederate states--Arkansas, Louisiana, and Tennessee--and also announced that when 10 percent of the voters in the rebel states (excluding high Confederate officials) pledged loyalty to the Union (including government actions concerning slavery) they would be readmitted to the Union.  Radicals denounced the "10 Percent Plan" as too lenient.  Congress in July 1864 adopted a much more radical measure, the Wade-Davis Bill, which required rebel states to abolish slavery, repudiate the Confederate war debt, disfranchise Confederate leaders, and require fifty percent of the citizens to pledge loyalty to the Union.  The radicals nominated General John C. Fremont for President, but he withdrew a month before the election.

     Lincoln feared that northern battlefield victories might be lost at the polls. During the summer of 1864, he confessed, "it seems exceedingly probable that this administration will not be reelected."  There seems little doubt that a McClellan victory would have resulted in an agreement to maintain slavery in the United States.

      The capture of Atlanta, a major southern railroad and manufacturing center, in September, electrified northern voters, who gave Lincoln a resounding victory.  He received 55 percent of the popular vote to just 21 percent for McClellan.

Grant Takes Command

spotsylvania court house
Spotsylvania Court House





sherman horseback
Sherman

     In March 1864, Lincoln gave Ulysses S. Grant command of all Union armies.  Vowing to end the war within a year, Grant launched three major offenses.  General Philip E. Sheridan's task was to lay waste to farm land in Virginia's Shenandoah valley, a mission he completed by October.  Meanwhile, General William Tecumseh Sherman advanced southeastward from Chattanooga and seized Atlanta, a major southern rail center, while Grant himself pursued Lee's army and sought to capture Richmond, the Confederate capital.

    Grant started his offensive with 118,000 men; by early June, half of his men were casualties.  But Lee's army had been reduced by a third to 40,000 men. In a month of fighting in northern and eastern Virginia, Grant lost almost 40,000 men, leading Peace Democrats to call him a "butcher."  But Confederate losses were also heavy--and southern troops could not be replaced.  At the Battle of the Wilderness, in northern Virginia, Lee's army suffered 11,000 casualties; at Spotsylvania Court House, Lee lost another 10,000 men.  After suffering terrible casualties at Cold Harbor--12,000 men killed or wounded--Grant advanced to Petersburg, a rail center south of Richmond, and began a nine-month siege of the city.

Grant's Wilderness Campaign

     Grant's ultimate objective in the Wilderness campaign was the capture of Richmond.  However, unlike his predecessors (most notably, McClellan), Grant refused to give up.  At every battle, General Lee managed to stop Grant's forces, but each time Grant simply outflanked Lee to the south (Grant's left flank), forcing another battle, and another flanking maneuver, and so on, until he had crossed the James River to face Lee at Petersburg.  Lee had told his subordinates that if Grant ever crossed the James, it was only a matter of time before the South would lose, and he was correct. 

     At the same time that Grant was pursuing Lee's army, Sherman, with a force of 100,000 men, marched toward Atlanta from Chattanooga, and captured the rail center on September 2, 1864.  After leaving Atlanta in flames, Sherman's men marched across Georgia toward Savannah.  In order to break the South's will to fight, Sherman had his men destroy railroad tracks, loot houses, and burn factories.  Sherman seized Savannah December 21, and then drove northward, capturing Charleston and Columbia, South Carolina, then heading through North Carolina to Virginia.  Sherman summed up the goal of his military maneuvers in grim terms: "We cannot change the hearts of those people, but we can make war so terrible...[and] make them so sick of war that generations would pass away before they would again appeal to it."

A Stillness at Appomattox
appamatox
Click on image for larger view
     By April 1865, Grant's army had cut off Lee's supply lines, forcing Confederate forces to evacuate Petersburg and Richmond. Lee and his men retreated westward, but Grant's troops overtook him about a hundred miles west of Richmond.  Recognizing that further resistance would be futile, Lee surrendered at Appomattox Court House, Virginia.  The aristocratic Lee wore a full-dress uniform, with a ceremonial sash and sword, while Grant wore a private's coat.

     The next day, in a final message to his troops, Robert E. Lee acknowledged that he was "compelled to yield to overwhelming numbers and resources."  Three-quarters of the Confederate white male population of military age had fought in the war, but by 1865, the North had four times as many troops as the Confederacy.  At the time he surrendered, Lee's entire army had shrunk to just 35,000 men, compared to Grant's total of 113,000.  Lee's decision to surrender, however, probably helped to prevent large-scale guerrilla warfare.

'The President is murdered'

john wilkes booth
John Wilkes Booth
lincoln assasination
The Assassination at Ford's Theater

     At noon on Good Friday, April 14, 1865, Major General Robert Anderson raised the U.S. flag over Fort Sumter.  It was the same flag that he had surrendered four years before.

     That evening, a few minutes after 10 o'clock, John Wilkes Booth (1838-1865), a young actor and Confederate sympathizer (who had spied for Richmond and been part of a plot to kidnap Lincoln), entered the presidential box at Ford's Theater in Washington and shot the President in the back of the head.  Booth then leaped to the stage, but he caught a spur in a flag draped in front of the box.  He fell and broke his leg. As he fled the theater he is said to have cried out: "Sic temper tyrannis"--thus always to tyrants, the motto of the State of Virginia.

     Simultaneously, a Booth accomplice, Lewis Paine, brutally attacked Secretary of State William Seward (1801-1872) at his home with a knife.  Seward survived because Paine's knife was deflected by a metal collar he wore from a severe accident.  Seward slowly recovered from his wounds and continued to serve as Secretary of State under Lincoln's successor, Andrew Johnson.

     Lincoln was carried unconscious to a neighboring house. He was pronounced dead at 7:22 a.m., April 15.  A few minutes later, Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton (1814-1869) stepped outside and announced to the assembled crowd, "he belongs to the ages."

     Following the shooting, Booth fled to Maryland on horseback.  A friend then helped him escape to Virginia. On April 26, two weeks after he had shot Lincoln, the army and Secret Service tracked Booth down and trapped him in a barn near Port Royal, Virginia.  When Booth refused to surrender, his pursuers set the barn on fire. Booth was found dead, apparently of a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

     Lincoln's assassination was part of a larger plot to murder other government officials, including Vice President Andrew Johnson, Secretary of State William H. Seward, and General Ulysses S. Grant.  Only Lincoln was killed.  Following the assassination, Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton ordered War Department agents to apprehend the conspirators.  Despite wild rumors of involvement by top Confederate officials, the actual conspirators included, apart from Booth, an ex-Confederate soldier, a carriage maker, and a druggist's clerk. Eight individuals were arrested; a military commission found all of them guilty.  Four were hanged.  Of the remaining four, one died in prison in 1867 and three others received presidential pardons in 1869.

     Many Northerners blamed the Confederate leadership for the President's death.  Anger and a thirst for vengeance against "traitors" were surely widespread.  This makes it all the more remarkable that the North's victory was not followed by a massive and bloody extermination of Confederate leaders and their northern sympathizers.

The War's Costs      As a result of the Civil War, the South lost a fourth of its white male population of military age, a third of its livestock, half of its farm machinery, and $2.5 billion worth of human property.  Factories and railroads had been destroyed, and such cities as Atlanta, Charleston, Columbia, and Richmond had been largely burned to the ground.  In South Carolina, the value of property plunged from $400 million in 1860, ranking it third in the nation, to just $50 million in 1865.



Sources
Digital History, "The Civil War," accessed November 2003.
Shotgun's Civil War, http://www.civilwarhome.com
Ken Burns' Civil War, http://www.pbs.org/

© Kahne Parsons, 2007-08